ASU lost, for all intents and purposes. If those were PAC-12 refs, puts another black mark on PAC-12 officiating.
No. Weirder things have happened than a kicker missing a 32-yd field goal with that kind of pressure, especially when considering that Wiscy's kickers only have made 57% over their careers.
Either way, I think you could make a legitimate comparison between the Pac 12 and the SEC this year. The SEC has the following BCS wins (AP rankings are current as of this week):
1-2 TCU (Neutral site, LSU)
1-1 NC (Home, SC)
2-1 WSU (Home, Auburn)
1-2 Texas (Away, Ole Miss)
2-1 VT (Neutral, Alabama)
Plus the following losses:
2-0 #3 Clemson (Neutral, SC)
3-0 #2 Oregon (Away, Tenn)
2-0 #16 Miami (away, Florida)
1-2 W. Kentucky (neutral, Kentucky)
3-0 #7 Louisville (Home, Kentucky)
3-0 #11 Ok. St (Home, Miss State)
The SEC is 5-5 against BCS competition
Conversely, the Pac has the following BCS wins:
1-1 Virginia (Away, Oregon)
2-1 Tenn (Home, Oregon)
2-1 Illinois (Away, Washington)
2-1 #24 Wisconsin (Home, ASU)
2-1 Nebraska (Away, UCLA)
2-1 Boston College (Home, USC)
And the following losses:
3-0 Auburn (away, WSU)
2-1 EWU (home, OSU)
3-0 #18 Northwestern (home, Cal)
3-0 #4 OSU (home, Cal)
the Pac is 6-3 vs. BCS competition