Bisonic,
I agree with your post.
Regarding Patton (and Barnett / previous football coaches, for that matter)... people need to realize that the old way of doing things at CU was not working any more and couldn't work. With the advent of the Big 12, we no longer could take partial qualifiers. That had to change our recruiting criteria. Further, with the APR instituted, we had another hit to the types of athletes we could have in our programs. Patton's team had like a 2.0 GPA and we took a scholarship penalty (GB's final APR seasons were well below the minimum APR and we'll have scholarship penalties in football, too). Further, the scandal tightened things on recruiting and conduct to almost Ivy League standards at CU. Finally, very little progress was made on facilities or revenue base (other than the Folsom luxury boxes) in the 15 years before Bohn took over.
Basically, the entire landscape changed and we weren't prepared for it. While Bohn has been focused on growing our revenue base, improving facilities, keeping the budget balanced, and making sure that our house was in order on academics and conduct... he's had to hire coaches with a mid-major mentality. Go inexpensive, work harder, and do things the right way.
So, what do we get?
Men's Basketball: Bzdelik. A guy who had 2 straight 20-win seasons at Air Force and put his final team in the NCAA tournament despite the difficulties of winning in basketball at service academies. Very high academic and personal conduct standards. Known for bringing top fundamentals, Xs and Os, and talent evaluation.
Women's Basketball: KMM and Lappe. Both young coaches who came cheaply for a program that doesn't make money for CU. KMM build a Tulsa program to respectability despite very little tradition or resources. Lappe is a hard worker, strong leader, and willing recruiter who is part of the Ceal Barry coaching tree. Loves CU and is loved by the player and coach alumni of the WBB program. Both demand strong academics and good off-court behavior from their players.
Football: Hawkins. A guy who had the highest winning % in the country while at mid-major power Boise State. Never had a recruiting violation attached to his name. Reputation for finding "hidden gems" in recruiting. Sincerely committed to developing the "whole person" with his athletes. Didn't require a huge salary.
Volleyball: Kritza. Young, energetic coach with ties to the state of Colorado. Had the leadership, recruiting savvy, and great system of play to rebuild the Tulane program to new heights even while recovering from Katrina and not even able to practice in their own facilities in the beginning. High character with very high standards for her players. Also came with a relatively low price tag in a sport that is losing money but could some day break even for us.
I believe that Bohn has a very clear vision for the type of coach that is needed at CU given our current situation. Since we're forced to take chances on people who come somewhat cheap and then ask them to do more with less than their Big 12 competition, we're going to miss on some hires. But I like the direction of the AD and I agree with Bohn's vision (even for the coach profile). I believe that Men's Basketball is on the right track for sustainable success. I believe that Kritza is going to end up building a program that will make her a CU legend. I'm in "wait and see" mode with Lappe, but feel like she could end up being great. And I believe that Hawkins has done some good things for CU football and will either win in 2010 to start a long run here or we'll replace him with a new coach who is stepping into a pretty good situation. (Soccer, Tennis, Track & Field, Golf and Skiing all seem to be in good hands too, fwiw.)
P.S. This is a rant I've been meaning to go on for a while. I don't expect most people to agree with me, but it's a point of view that doesn't get voiced enough imo. Sometimes, I think that people who support things stay a bit quiet these days because they don't want to deal with being ridiculed as a "sunshine pumper" or one of the nastier monikers.