I don't think that each guy we have committed is a future star, each has downsides including Dillon. If you look at most recruiting classes including those of the schools considered to have top 10 type classes a high percentage of recruits underachieve. a good percentage, including the so called blue chips never see any significant playing time. I could give a potential downside to every recruit on our list but it wouldn't be productive at this point.
I do differ with you on the comparison to Hawkins classes. His early classes looked to be solid, with a few very notable recruits. His 2008 class included seven 4* and a 5*, most from out of state. Granted of those Katoa never played, MTM was damaged goods and had a limited career, Givens came as a result of the kNU meltdown as did Mohler. Look to 2009 and he had four 4* players, Nuckols who never qualified (the reason he was available to us, if his academics were decent he would have never committed to us,) Simmons who barely saw the field, Harris and Kasa who were both in state. Zero out of state 4*s contributed and much of the rest of the class were marginal or leftovers (some will be good players but they weren't highly though of by other BCS AQ conference schools, 2010 included exactly one 4* player, Richardson who signed with UCLA and transfered after being connected to of field issues. Many of the rest of the class had few if any AQ conference offers.
I am not a huge fan of the star system and looking at reported other offers also has its failings but can be a reasonable factor to consider. Compared to Hawks last two classes we are way ahead of where he was at this point. Not on target for a top 10 or even a top 20 class yet but I do honestly think every guy committed has the potential to be a solid contributor, not something I could say the last few years.
If Walk is being honest then he probably should look for another team to support or even a different sport than college football. If he can't find positives in the guys we have including Thomas then he has an attitude problem.