I'm a new Buff fan - just got into grad school here and am pumped to root for the team. I'm playing catch up here, so I was digging through the rivals commitment lists from the past 5 years. What I found was interesting in that pretty much every player on the roster is a 5.7 or lower recruit. The only guys above that are Ryan Miller (6.1), Ryan Deehan (5.8), Ray Polk (5.8), Bryce Givens (5.9), Jon Major (5.9), Jack Harris (5.8),Nick Kasa (6.0), and Paul Richardson (5.8). Eight guys over five classes, and only 5 are starters at the position they were recruited. More interesting was the number of guys who left the program. Here's the list I had. Let me know if I missed anyone.
2010
Donnie Duncan -5.6—athlete-CA–did not qualify academically
Justin Favors -5.4-TE-OH- did not qualify academically
Henley Griffon -5.4-TE-FL-kicked off team 4/11
Trea Jones- 5.5-RB-NC-left team after freshman season
Harold Mobley -5.7-athlete/TE-CA-kicked off team 4/11
Dakota Poole –NR-DE-BC- Medically unable to compete
Justin Torres -5.2-Athlete-CA-left team 10/10 due to homesickness
2009
Clark Evans-5.6-QB/TE-ruled ineligible and transferred
Will Jefferson-NR-WR-CA-medically unable to compete
Edward Nuckols-5.8-DT-CA-attending Seton Hall (PA)
Andre Simmons-5.8-WR-KS-did not qualify for 2010 and left team
Shaun Simon-5.4-OL-OK-attending JUCO
Terdema Ussery-5.6-WR-TX-left team in 2010 on personal leave and did not return
J Forrest West-5.3-DE-CT-kicked of team 4/11
2008
Chance Blackmon-5.6-WR-TX-left program after 2008 season
Jameson Davis-4.9-K-ID-medically unable to compete
Steven Hicks-5.6-DB-TX-left program before 2010 season
Lynn Katoa-6.0-LB-UT-suspended due to academics and discipline, left program after 08 season
Darnell Scott-6.1-HB-CA-left program and transferred to South Florida
Max Tuioti-Mariner-5.9-OL-CA-medically unable to compete
Ryan Wallace-5.5-TE-KY-left program in May 09 due to homesickness
2007
Matt Ballenger-5.6-QB-ID-released to pursue other schools 04/09
Kendrick Celestine-5.5-WR-LA-left due to homesickness 09/08
PT Gates-6.0-HB-CA-did not qualify academically and ended up at Grand Valley St
Eugene Goree-5.0-DT-TN-left team 03/11
Devan Johnson-5.3-HB-PA-grayshirt who never enrolled
Kealaki Maiava-5.2-OL-HI-tranferred from program prior to 08
Chris Perri-5.4-DT-CA-dismissed from team 2008
Lagrone Shields-5.5-DE-TN-left team in 2009
Markques Simas-5.8-WR-CA- Academically ineligible for 08 season, suspended and left team
Josh Smith-5.5-Ath-CA- played as a freshman and in 2009 transferred back home to UCLA
Lamont Smith-5.4-DB-PA-academic issues, left team in 2007
Nate Vaiomounga-5.5-LB-CA-academically ineligible for 08 season, then booted for rules violation
Anthony Wright-5.7-DB-CA-medically unable to compete
On that list are six guys above a 5.7:Gates (6.0), Simas (5.8), Katoa (6.0), Scott (6.1), Tuioti-Mariner (5.9), and Nuckols (5.8). I know all programs get hit with attrition, and recruit rankings have a very high failure rate, but when you don't recruit many talented guys and loose almost half of them it's still gotta hurt.
I'm just happy to welcome a new era with Embree. Hope he has more success bringing in and retaining talent....and most importantly winning football games.