Why is CTE speculation inappropriate? It has been a factor in multiple suicides of former football players.
in general, I think it's in poor taste to speculate why some one did something like kill themselves, especially on a public message board in a thread commemorating their contributions, especially when the suicide hadn't been confirmed. even more especially where the preponderance of posts are fans lamenting the loss and reflecting on the contributions the player made to the team and the community.
in this specific case of contrasting those posts with the content of the DP article, (1) there was far less speculation in the article than there was here on Allbuffs (2) I didn't read anything in the article which came across to me as either inappropriate or insensitive, with the possible exception of the headline, which I think was more odd than inappropriate (3) the chief complaint with the article from Allbuffers was that Kizla seemed to be concluding suicide before it was official, and that was no different than what Allbuffers were posted (no question, the standard for journalists should be higher than random message board posters, but I don't understand how one can rationalize that it's acceptable for them to speculate the death was a suicide but not for Kizla to do so).
However, since we're speculating, from national sports news in the 1990's and google searching the last few days, i didn't find much info suggesting that RS had suffered concussions as a player. Does anyone have historical information on this that would lead to the CTE speculation?
Last, three notes of context:
1. I've been a Buff fan for only 3 years, which means I don't have the same emotional perspective on RS's loss as many here
2. I haven't developed the same preconceived expectations around Mr. Kizla's journalism
3. I believe the recent trend of elevated concern over concussions resulting from football has the potential to destroy the sport I love. If I'm being 100% honest, I'm not above taking steps to quiet that discussion, even if I believe the concerns are valid at a logical level.