He was P12 HM as a soph last year, though.
Well I thought you said the options were:
an All-Conference Honorable Mention or better performance
So I will go with Sefo for "better". If he can play at a solidly improved level statistically, it will say a lot of things about how his supporting cast played as well as his decision making.
Defense: a pass rusher would make the biggest impact on that side from an individual standpoint.