I do not expect a top 15 class, sorry if my post was not clearer. I was trying to point out to MtnBuff that he brings up that mythical expectation pretty much every time this topic comes up and no one on Allbuffs has said anything of the sort.
My expectation for the 2012 class continues to be a top 30-35 class.
Been away from the board most of the day as I will be the next few days.
Top 30-35 classes are reasonable to expect, at least top 40 and close to middle of the PAC for the next couple of years.
Beyond that 3-5 years out, once they have had time to establish recruiting networks and camp relationships, and should have an identity established on the field and in the locker room then it would be reasonable to expect them to move up into the 20's which is the level of talent needed at a minimum if you are hoping to have a consistent shot at going to a conference championship game.
Understand that I have no problem with holding the coaches and the program to reasonable benchmarks and expecting to see quantifiable progress. We had enough of the feel good, karma and coconuts crap with Hawkins. That is what got us into this mess we are in right now.
My only argument is that we have a right to expect reasonable progress and legitimate evidence of that. This means recruits that for the most part coaches other than our own think can play at this level. This means competing in the games on the field against schools that have similar talent to ours on a consistent basis. This means looking like and acting like a major college football team.
As bad as the situation was for Embree and company coming into this year I am okay with the progress I have seen so far. I am optimistic based on the commits we have so far and hope for (and expect at least one or two) pleasant surprises in recruiting before LOI day. On the field we are still undisciplined and lack heart but at least we can get a play in and get lined up without 3-5 delay of game penalties and illegal formation penalties.
My recruiting benchmark for this year is a little lower than yours but not much, next year I would expect both of us to move it a step us. I also expect to see a more productive off-season and to see progress on the field next year in terms of wins and in terms of competitiveness in the games we don't win.
I do believe that some people here have unreasonable expectations of Embree and Co.
at this time. At no time do I say that we shouldn't have expectations, only that even with our frustrations those expectations should be reasonable in light of the time frame and situation.
If we are not reaching benchmarks and we don't have a significantly better program 2 years from now, don't waste time like we did last time, make the change.