You do have to ask yourself how often we got a true title game in the past few years and how often teams got in based on reputation, media pressure etc.
Exactly. I feel pretty confident that we have the 2 best teams playing in the big game.
You do have to ask yourself how often we got a true title game in the past few years and how often teams got in based on reputation, media pressure etc.
To me, Oregon was clearly the better team across the board.
I feel a little dirty cheering so hard for Oregon.
For a year when CU is not participating, this has gone about as well as I could have hoped.
1. CSU lost.
2. Nebraska lost.
3. Texas lost.
4. Baylor lost.
5. Playoff is a blast.
6. New Year's Day is king again.
7. Pac-12 dominating while SEC faltering. Now a legit conversation on which conference is #1.
Good times.
I'm not a fan of any of the final four teams, but that didn't stop me from enjoying every second of both games and loving the outcome of each.
An Oregon win will make those goofs insufferable. The t-shirt fans will come out of the woodwork and we'll be seeing neon green and highlighter yellow "o"s everywhere. It'll be awful, but in the end, it's great for college football and won't really hurt CU, either.
The two better teams won imho. FSU hurt themselves with turnovers but a few of those were forced. Oregon deserves credit not like Winston gave them any.
Yeah I don't think he played terrible by any stretch, I was more referring to that rb more than anything. Also what Winston said after the game.Winston played well until FSU self destructed and he had to chase the game and therefore force things.
To me, Oregon was clearly the better team across the board.
I feel a little dirty cheering so hard for Oregon.
Before the games I would have said no one. After today it was evident that fsu was living on borowed time. I would have paid to watch tcu vs the quacks.
The conference championship games are almost a defacto playoff game. Not having one in the Big 12 helped screw TCU.
The conference championship games are almost a defacto playoff game. Not having one in the Big 12 helped screw TCU.
For a year when CU is not participating, this has gone about as well as I could have hoped.
1. CSU lost.
2. Nebraska lost.
3. Texas lost.
4. Baylor lost.
5. Playoff is a blast.
6. New Year's Day is king again.
7. Pac-12 dominating while SEC faltering. Now a legit conversation on which conference is #1.
Good times.
Leave it to the 'smiteful' gods of football to stick us in the toughest division while trying to rebuild.Best division, too. ASU, UA, USC, UCLA and Utah should all be ranked in the final poll.
Are you admitting that the playoff was actually a good idea?0. Virginia Tech Military Bowl Champs. :woot: :woot:
0. Wisconsin Badgers Outback Bowl Champs. :woot:
1. enjoy the Schadenfreude
2. ditto
3. by God, does it have no end?
4. CU fans need something to cheer for besides other teams losing.
5. the playoff games have been good. I'll withhold further comment. I sincerely hope that everyone who has been wanting this is enjoying the games and the objective process of determining who is the "one true national champion for all of college football".
6. Yes, and that's good. However, I thought I was going to love having a full slate of big New Years games, but DVR has given me back control of my sports viewing schedule, so it wasn't that big of a deal to me. also, honestly with the timing of the holidays and weekend, I'd probably rather have them on Wed night or on Saturday.
7. wikipedia has a good page for this season's bowl summary. Pac does look good. Big game for UCLA today. No idea about the OSU/Wash game.
Are you admitting that the playoff was actually a good idea?
I didn't read your post either. Just hoping. How anyone can watch yesterdays games and still think it was terrible idea is crazy to me. To each their own, I guess.I re-read my post and can't conceive how any person could take that away from anything I said. No, I think the playoffs were a terrible idea. i think fans were pushed into really shi*ty systems like the BSA and BCS which screwed things up so bad that fans believed the networks (who stand to make all the money) telling us that we needed a playoffs. Few stopped to question, "why?"
I didn't read your post either. Just hoping. How anyone can watch yesterdays games and still think it was terrible idea is crazy to me. To each their own, I guess.
Leave it to the 'smiteful' gods of football to stick us in the toughest division while trying to rebuild.
I didn't read your post either. Just hoping. How anyone can watch yesterdays games and still think it was terrible idea is crazy to me. To each their own, I guess.
Agreed. Was a huge proponent of the 8 team playoff, but yesterday was so good I can an argument for leaving it as is.I agree with this. Yesterday was all kinds of incredible. It might be so good that the 8-team playoff might not happen. The 4-team playoff keeps the regular season very much in play. You can't back in to the final four.
Jens nearly has me convinced that we should keep it at 4 teams. While 8 teams sounds terrific, I think it might dilute the value of the regular season a bit. There was no question that those four teams deserved to be there. It also helps that they kept the bowl games intact and worked them into the fabric of the playoff. That was genius. So next week, either OSU or UO will lose, but they can still say they're Sugar Bowl/Rose Bowl champions. That's great.
I haven't enjoyed a NYD that much in years. Maybe since 1991.
can we honestly not differentiate between "the quality of the games" and "the appropriateness of the system"? I think you and a few others are conflating those points.
opcorn:can we honestly not differentiate between "the quality of the games" and "the appropriateness of the system"? I think you and a few others are conflating those points.
I think it will expand to 8 eventually.