It was there for everyone to see freshman year. He was the least competant of the four freshmen that year, of which that class has been a disappointment and significantly responsible for 15-17.
Agree(except with the sp). But competency is a combination of learned skills and mental acuity, both of which can be taught and added to by maturity. No one doubts his athleticism or physical tools are D1.
Doesn't hurt anyone for him to RS. I'll give Tad benefit of the doubt on his RS. His schollie wouldn't have made a difference in last year's dumpster fire.