I actually thought TACKLING got worse this year over 2013. We actually had guys in position to make the tackles more often than I've seen in a long time. And they just didn't.
We give him 2015, the results better damn well change. I'm tired of all this don't be physical in practice crap too. Guys that got hurt, with my experience in football, were not prepared to be hit. I know concussions but this game is physical as well as mental, don't take that away from what you do. Go full speed, all the time.
Do they tackle? I mean put the man on the ground.It may be the culture in youth sports, but not college sports
On full pad days they do from my observationsDo they tackle? I mean put the man on the ground.
agree. Next year we need to improve in three areas defensively. 1 more take aways 2. 3rd down stops to get off the fields and 3. Reduce the gashing long runs. If we improve there we will be fine if not Baer should be replaced.So, with our defense being more experienced and improving, Baer and his defense should NOT be giving up 38 points or more to every pac team we play correct? Fine he gets 2015 to show improvement but if we get the same a change needs to be made. If you cant recruit you better be coaching up the talent you do have.
The defense of Baer is hilarious.
I would add if we could substantially upgrade any staff position without messing up the chemistry we should take that chance. For example if we could get Orgeron as a dc we should. My point is that Baer may not be bad and dc is too important to shake things up unless there is a big upside. Baer and Neinas have not necessarily been bad. Certainly not bad enough to fire. Neinas (and maybe a few other coaches, special team blunders and lack of game changing plays have been more obvious) appears from the outside to be average and could be upgraded with better recruiter or coach or both. Baer is harder to read and would be a riskier shake up to the staff.agree. Next year we need to improve in three areas defensively. 1 more take aways 2. 3rd down stops to get off the fields and 3. Reduce the gashing long runs. If we improve there we will be fine if not Baer should be replaced.
I would add if we could substantially upgrade any staff position without messing up the chemistry we should take that chance. For example if we could get Orgeron as a dc we should. My point is that Baer may not be bad and dc is too important to shake things up unless there is a big upside. Baer and Neinas have not necessarily been bad. Certainly not bad enough to fire. Neinas (and maybe a few other coaches, special team blunders and lack of game changing plays have been more obvious) appears from the outside to be average and could be upgraded with better recruiter or coach or both. Baer is harder to read and would be a riskier shake up to the staff.
Why? Because I think in general this staff is good and they are on the verge of climbing out of this hole. There are many signs we are improving and headed for good things. I would hate to blow up the staff just before they get it going. Changing the coordinator is close enough to blowing up the staff to warrant moving cautiously.Why? Afraid to lose the momentum of a two win season?
Maybe not if the new coordinator runs a similar defense with mmac providing continuity. But I am not sure Baer is that bad and replacing the DC is a pretty big deal that could go either way. Giving Baer another year seams reasonable. Who do you think would have done a better job coaching our d last year?Changing a coordinator is blowing up a staff? Come on!
Maybe not if the new coordinator runs a similar defense with mmac providing continuity. But I am not sure Baer is that bad and replacing the DC is a pretty big deal that could go either way. Giving Baer another year seams reasonable. Who do you think would have done a better job coaching our d last year?
First, I want to say that I'm glad we have differing opinions on the board. Stick to your guns.
Second, I want to say that I disagree with you. The defense did not perform. There are a lot of reasons why it justifiably struggled this season, but good coordination can overcome challenges to at least show improvement from a bad 2013 defense that didn't lose much of anything to graduation. Lindgren had a ton of challenges on offense but he overcame them. The biggest complaint I had about the defense in regard to Baer is that LBs are his position group and they looked lost out there way too often this season.