How do you compare the rosters they inherited to ours? Rodriguez, at least, has had major success at a BCS school.
It´s difficult, yes, but I don´t believe Arizona, who if memory serves lost quite a few seniors also, has significantly better talent than we do.
If you want to try, here are the Scout recruiting class rankings for Arizona, Arizona State and CU since 2007. Going by this, which is obviously flawed, Arizona´s talent should be somewhere in our ballpark.
The thing is, and the point I am disputing, is that the next coach will have to pull players based on his name alone. Rich Rod is proving that you can win with the talent inherited from someone else. And that gives you something to sell.
Arizona
2007 49
2008 39
2009 47
2010 39
2011 70
2012 46
AVERAGE 48,3
Arizona State
2007 28
2008 17
2009 36
2010 26
2011 64
2012 43
AVERAGE 37,3
Colorado
2007 35
2008 27
2009 57
2010 70
2011 62
2012 29
AVERAGE 46,6