I was referring to the definition of plagiarism and not the "idea" of plagiarism. Guess that's our disconnect. Maybe I should take one of your seminars.
View attachment 15400
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Because I was posting in a thread in the very same forum as the reference post, I believe that the association was implied, insomuch as it matters, which is to say, not all, on a chat site.
Allbuffs is highly dependent on referencing material--nearly none of it cited. When somebody makes a factual statement, then sometimes a citation is requested, and that's valid for facts, but what you're requesting, or insinuating is something else altogether.
When I teach my seminar, we don't spend a lot of time on plagiarism, but when we touch on the topic its in context of the university's policy, which is dependent on the concepts of both originality and intent. My intent, I believe, was clear to everybody except for you, for some reason.
You seem comfortable with my use of a National Lampoon's Vacation quote, a Brittney Spears quote and a Bon Jovie quote--all without citation. Presumably that's because you believe there is shared knowledge of those references. So how is a tweet, imbedded in the same forum in which I was posting somehow LESS shared knowledge than the other references? In a sense, the fresher the reference the better. At some point "Was it over when the Germans burned Pearl Harbor" becomes a little tedious.
And let's face it--citing the reference of a joke whose point is to draw in a reference would be less than effective as a technique. "Well according to Faux Pelini, there are 37 humps!"
Also, that we're arguing about what I believed to be an obvious reference to somebody pretending to be Bo Pelini in the first place, isn't lost on me.
So I'll ask again. When it comes to making references to other material as a joke, are there rules? How old does the reference have to be (1980s era movies okay, but a tweet from two days ago is not?)? What media can you reference (movies and songs are fine, but no social media?)?
Or can we just assume that as we banter on Allbuffs, we can reference other threads, posts, social events, news and media products in a light-hearted way without worrying that somebody will accuse us of plagiarism because for once they actually got the reference?