No charges were ever filed, but leaks were happening out of the DA immediately, and the players were thrown under the bus of public opinion by having their pictures put on the front page of the paper as rapists....and CU did nothing, absolutely nothing to defend them. One of the players that had his picture plastered on the front page, was proven later to not even have been in town during the party, and there was nary a word of retraction or apology.
Re: the public opinion issue, Cindy Carlisle was a regent, and absolutely refused to recuse herself from the issue even though her husband was representing the main accuser. Cindy is dirty, hates football, and leveraged this to her family's benefit (and to the detriment of CU FB), and no one had the spine to call her on it.
It happened at a unique time in CU Sports. There were 3 distinct news outlets competing for stories at the time (BDC, DP, and the Rocky Mountain News)....this is unusual for a university, and it resulted in these news outlets blowing up the story in an effort to attract eyeballs....then it went national and all bets were off because (again) no one at CU had the spine to stand up for the kids or the truth. That's what makes Buffaloed so unique. Bruce Plasket was a beat reporter for the Longmont Times Call, and he saw what the media was doing to the team, what Cindy Carlisle was doing, what the University was not doing....and he published the book with his own money and at great personal expense to himself (in an effort to tell the truth as he saw it). The whole thing was completely ****ed.
And yes, the bowl of condoms was real, and that really happened. No criminal charges were ever filed against anyone, and the accusers mostly walked away with a fat pay day.