I'm no basketball guy so you that are can chime in. First, to run a fast or faster paced offense with a lot of motion, there is a premium on the point guard. Does this new philosophy say anything about Collier? Does Tad see him as a guy that can run an up tempo offense the next 2 or 3 or however many years? Second, I would think a more exciting, up tempo offense would be a positive for recruiting. I lived in Vegas when Tark and the Runnin' Rebs were making waves. They were a blast to watch. And, no, I don't think that is the style we are going to.
DBT,
Good questions.
First, I think there's a misperception about PG. Our old offense actually put more of a premium on the position since he was expected to get the team into a set and to orchestrate the offense. In the case of Spencer, he was also expected to find points for us by beating a defender one-on-one if the play didn't result in anything.
If you look at faster-paced, motion offenses it becomes more of the NBA thing. The Spurs don't have a traditional PG. Tony Parker is a score-first guy. So is his backup, Patty Mills. Manu is probably a better passer from the "2". Boris Diaw was a very valuable "point forward" and they drafted Kyle Anderson to get a young guy developing in that role.
The 2 titles before them won by the Heat was with teams that had LeBron as a "point forward" dominating action and forcing ball movement. If you go back to the Lakers and Bulls teams that won titles under Phil Jackson, none of them had a great PG and the action was dominated from the "2".
What I'm getting at is that this offense and the modern game is about having all the guys moving and finding open players. Tad can very easily have 3 combo guards on the court without anyone in a traditional PG role.
So, yes, Collier can be great in this setup. So can a guy like Dorsey. Or Ski. It allows them to develop and showcase PG skills while not having to sacrifice their scoring (like a Tony Parker or a Russell Westbrook).
That's appealing to recruits.
Fast pace is also appealing to recruits. Scoring is fun. Running and dunking is fun. Dropping a dime to a teammate is fun. An important note here is that Tad emphasized defense and rebounding so much and those things aren't fun. They're dirty. They're hard. They don't show up much on the stat sheet or ESPN highlights. But they win basketball games and defensive skill gets players drafted. But to get players to buy in to the degree needed in those areas, you've got to let them have fun at the other end. Calipari is the master of that. Pitino is another master. I have hope that with what Tad is doing he is learning from their success.