Defense
DL: On 2nd viewing, they got dominated worse than I thought but since I knew who played and didn't play on 2nd viewing, I understood why. Nyles Gaddy and Tru Thompson are by far the two best players on the DL and are superior run-stoppers compared to the rest. Neither played due to injuries. Their rotational players are just specialists. Three of those guys have real size, Williams, Gattis, and Evans. Evans and Gattis entered the portal. Basically, Williams was the only rotation player with size that played. Against a run-heavy team with a big strong mobile for this level QB, that's a recipe for disaster and boy was it a disaster. This reminds me of Alabama-UGA in last year's title game. Injuries killed their WR core and J. Williams got hurt early in the game, so the team that dominated UGA in the SEC Title game with Metchie and Williams, was basically playing Bryce Young hero ball in the national title game. Injuries are a part of the game but if bookies knew about these injuries, I believe many would have said this game would be a toss-up instead of a 13.5 point spread for JSU.
LB: On 2nd viewing were better than I thought. They missed more tackles than previously but their coverage was pretty good and they took away a lot of EASY throws from Richard. Their run stopping was underwhelming but they had to do a lot more than what's been previously asked of them. Miller was much better on 2nd watch than I thought.
CBs: On 2nd viewing, they did get beat a couple of times. Hunter and Bolden both once. But most of the completions were kept in front of them or within the scheme. I felt they played very well.
S: Huggins had an excellent game but Shilo Sanders and Cam struggled BADLY. On 2nd viewing, Cam got put in some terrible situations thanks to the depleted DL as a box-to-box safety and his lack of size was exposed but Shilo was worse on 2nd viewing. His tackling was sound but he wasn't in the right spots. Then he was heavily picked on for both the running and passing game. Especially passing. They wanted as much 1v1 on Shilo and usually, Shilo is protected so he can hover but when the running game is killing you like it was, you get better matchups with 8 in the box and Shilo was getting picked on badly. He might have been just as exposed as the DL but the DL has a good reason, most of their personnel fits for this matchup were out. Truth is, Huggins should have got all of Sanders's PT and maybe JSU would still win regardless of DL being depleted.
Coaching: Was the defense prepped, honestly, I don't feel like they were. D-. Playcalling was D- as well. It just felt like the defense was bad and had no organization and was constantly bickering with each other. By far, JSU's worst defensive game this year and the 2nd worse of the Prime era. 1st was Alabama A&M who won the Black National Title in the Spring and dominated JSU badly but that defense had no DL talent yet and was still using the previous coach's roster. Deion cut most of those guys. This was his worst game by a mile with Deion's roster. A big part of this lost is on Prime. He shouldn't have talked trash after Evans and Gattis entered the portal saying no one who's a starter entered the portal. Well in this game, they would have been starters and would have clearly helped A LOT. Losing them also had an impact on this game so Prime gets the defensive blame for this game even more than Thurman.
Special Teams: You can't allow a trick play. That right there drops the ST grade to a C but otherwise, it was good for the most part.
I felt NC Central outcoached JSU and did whatever it took to win. JSU kept it more basic than usual and they are normally the aggressive ones. Today, that was NC Central. Prime got out-coached. Must learn from this when he goes to Colorado. I do think NC Central having a month to prep for this game is a massive advantage. If Richard had to play two weeks ago in a championship game, he would have likely had to play with a broken finger this game could have been far less effective and they could have had other injuries. JSU and the SWAC gotta change that. If the SWAC has a conference title game, so should the MEAC. It's only fair.