I guess I'll stand up as the lone Hawk supporter. I really don't see the benefit of firing him after this season. If we fire Hawk know we are basically asking for another 3-4 years of rebuilding--why not let Hawk have a season in which we have a mature O-line, a more experienced QB (Hansen), and an improved D-line.
At this time last year I agreed with what you are saying and I will admit that I was one of many who thought that hiring Hawk was a great get when he came in.
I am also a believer that the "good old days of Barnett" weren't that good and that considering that he had not recruited a decent class in two years and had the media scandal over his head he had to go. When Hawk got here the cupboard really was bare, we had little talent, no depth, and worse prospects.
I will give Hawk credit for significantly bringing up the level of recruiting at most positions, we now have a lot of quality young talent. I will also give him credit for cleaning up the media image of the program which is now generally much more positive than even before the so-called scandal hit. I will also give him credit for getting the team up for a few great games including almost beating Georgia, beating OU, beating WVU (once), and this year beating a highly respected Kansas team.
That all said after four years there is no way to excuse the repeated miserable performances like we saw on Saturday. There is no excuse for getting not only beat but kicked by CSU, Toledo, KjSU, all teams that are significantly less talented than we are.
There is no excuse for losing to Montana State, Iowa State, Baylor, almost losing to LOL Eastern Washington.
Hawk insist on screwing around with this team to play his son in his system. I can understand playing Mcknight because he has earned it but to play Ebner and Espy at WR in your fourth year in the program leaves no excuse. We are playing an Adams State recieving corp.
I love the OL talent Hawk has brought in but again they have no continuity, lack individual skill development and have no idea where they stand since they can be praised one week and on the bench the next, just like every other player on the team, at a Hawk whim.
Lastly, what makes you think that there will be significant improvement when in the fourth year of the program, with the coaches son who is supposed to be playing because of his intelligence and mastery of the offense, we can't get a play called, line up, and snapped before the play clock expires on frequent occasions including starting the second half and coming off of time-outs.