Just to put it out there. Tyler's stats for the season:
98 Completions on 173 Attempts (56.6%) - pretty average, 1325 Yards in four games - pretty average, 11 TDs and 2 INT - nothing bad there but he could have had several more interceptions because he does make some pretty questionable decisions. 37 Rushes for 28 Yards and 2 TDs - nothing spectacular there either... but Tyler has shown glimpses of having that athleticism that creates problems for defenses. I thought he moved around in the pocket particularly well in the second half of the WSU game.
Looking at that it is obvious that Tyler is not going to go out and be a stud QB for us, but I also do not think he is going to go out and lose games for us. He is a capable journeyman and if our play-makers on offense can do something once they get the ball we can put up points. Need to run better, need to catch better (all of the WRs - including P-Rich are dropping the ball TOO MUCH! Clemons looks like he has club hands unless he happens to be in the end zone or ridiculously wide open - he needs to concentrate and realize that a catch for a 1st down is just as important as a TD... just less glamorous).
Tyler needs to make better decisions and spread it around better. He had tons of time to make good throws in the second half but couldn't seem to spot the open receiver or be able to commit to a throw. There were several downs where I watched him pat the ball three or four times and still not get it out. If you have time to pat the ball four times you have time to find your RB in the flat or to find a running lane yourself. He is too focused on P-Rich in my opinion and overlooks or doesn't have the confidence in his other receivers. Perhaps this is rightly so as Clemons drops almost everything, Bahr and Deehan don't have the best hands either and I think Gray, Cefalo, and McCulloch seem capable but not brilliant.
Not all of the blame should be laid at Tyler's feet, but he may be the best we have to work with and it is true that he has not had the best coaching in the past. No one has seen Hirschman play in a game and I doubt that we will this year unless there is and injury to Tyler or Embree just gets so tired of losing that he tries something different. I doubt there will be a QB controversy here anytime this season and we can hope for Woods, Dillon, Schrock, or Hirschman to step up next season.