Let’s play devils advocate again than. If Saban came from Alabama, yes his recruiting would probably be the same.
Saban previous to Alabama, do we think he builds the dynasty here he has at Alabama? We don’t have the pipeline of talent in Colorado like Alabam has access to. We recruit from much further away.
Alabama is in an awesome spot for players. Colorado can get the players. We just haven’t been dedicated to being national championship caliber for a long time.
I know it is a long time back but fact is that McCartney was recruiting at the level in his day that Bama is now. We had 9 out of 11 starters on a defense drafted including multiple first rounders.
Bama is in a good spot to recruit to but they also are in the middle of a bunch of competition for those same recruits.
If a Saban came to Colorado and the administration supported him (like Gordon Gee supported Bill McCartney) then yes we would dominate the PAC and be a yearly contender in the playoff.