MacIntyre needs to make a bowl game.
It's actually pretty simple.
Saying the same thing over and over doesn't magically make it true.You guys might want to pay attention to this post.
Why. There is very little room for improvement between this year and a bowl game. This year was not acceptable. All signs point to a bowl game. Simply doubting that without reason seems... Contrary for the reason of being contraryI don't think it's that simple, frankly. I think there's more at play than wins and losses.
Saying the same thing over and over doesn't magically make it true.
Fact is none of us knows for sure what the criteria is for keeping MM. It's worth the discussion, but I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss opposing viewpoints simply because they don't agree with your take on things.
You guys might want to pay attention to this post.
Do you and/or nik have some serious inside information?Nik did not post that just to repeat something.
Do you and/or nik have some serious inside information?
Let's just say Nik would not make that post without knowing what the clear expectations are for the 2016 season.
You guys might want to pay attention to this post.
I think RG is not happy with modest improvement. I think the rope is shorter than most of you think.RG said, two seasons ago, that his expectation was to make a bowl game. He's trying to sell this program to boosters. He's trying to raise $105 million plus. Not making a bowl game would make for a very difficult sell. We are a much more desireable job than we were after Embree. We will be an experienced team next year and will lose much of that experience in '17. Alparently RG was visibly and vocally upset after the Utah loss. All of this adds up to Mac being released if he does not get us to a bowl game.
The bottom line is MM is 10-27 with few conference wins, no signature wins, not even an upset (except in the wrong direction). At some point, incremental progress isn't enough, especially with the offense having regressed and the unfathomable special teams play.
doubting just to doubt is fine, but I'd say that your doubt is based on less evidence than those who think it's bowl game or bust.There's a whole lot of definitive statements being thrown around which makes me wonder if there is some inside info that the rest of us don't know about. If it's nothing more than reading between the lines from the latest AD update, I'd be cautious of making any conclusions based on what was said there.
What evidence? The AD newsletter where RG says he's disappointed with the results of the season? There's a big leap from that to "MM is fired if he doesn't make a bowl game in 2016". If there's other evidence, please show it to me. Honestly, I could have missed it.doubting just to doubt is fine, but I'd say that your doubt is based on less evidence than those who think it's bowl game or bust.
What evidence? The AD newsletter where RG says he's disappointed with the results of the season? There's a big leap from that to "MM is fired if he doesn't make a bowl game in 2016". If there's other evidence, please show it to me. Honestly, I could have missed it.
That's usually the kind of thing that gets posters excoriated around here. "I know something you don't know, but I can't tell you, so you'll just have to believe me."I think what all of them are saying is that they have evidence, that they can't show you. Saying as much as they can without actually saying it.
That's usually the kind of thing that gets posters excoriated around here. "I know something you don't know, but I can't tell you, so you'll just have to believe me."
Every single thing RG has said about the football team points to it going back to his long term goals for the program. Other circumstantial evidence: The recruiting class we need next year. The size of the senior and junior classes next year. Insider rumblings.What evidence? The AD newsletter where RG says he's disappointed with the results of the season? There's a big leap from that to "MM is fired if he doesn't make a bowl game in 2016". If there's other evidence, please show it to me. Honestly, I could have missed it.
Every single thing RG has said about the football team points to it going back to his long term goals for the program. Other circumstantial evidence: The recruiting class we need next year. The size of the senior and junior classes next year. Insider rumblings.
Plus, your alternate theory (more incremental improvement of what, one more win, and it's fine) has even less evidence beyond being illogical.