Secondary ought to be the same Are you kidding? They are replacing both CBs and one of those was very good. At best the secondary is completely unknown, at worst it is a step back.
My take on the original article is that, from the outside looking in, it's right on target. I believe Hawkins in on the right track and the Buffs will surprise people this year. Surprising people means that the team has a lot of unknowns or isn't expected to do great things.
Total unknowns (IMHO):
OL - They will gel or not. To me this is the key to the entire season. The articles statistics about Cody playing well when the running game is going is right on.
Running game - In addition to the OL being an unknown, the running game is as well. Will Sumler and/or Lockridge step up? Is Scott as good as advertised? We all want to think so, but it doesn't mean anything until it happens on the field.
Secondary - Losing Wheatley & Burney hurts. I know everyone focuses on TWheat but Burney was solid on the other side last year (watch the end of the OU game again if you have any doubt about that).
Pass Rush - Why exactly do you think this is going to get better? The only answer could possibly be, "because it can't get worse".
If all of those fall into place well, the Buffs are looking at a breakout season but that's a lot of IFs.
Twheat and Burney are being replaced by Jimmy Smith and Gardner McKay. I don't think that is a huge drop off. There is a reason that TWheat was only supposed to be a 4th round pick until he ran a great 40 time; he had a so-so senior year. And is Dykes going to benefit from having a year in the big 12 under his belt? Is Ryan Walters going to have a big senior year? I think so. Is Jimmy Smith going to keep improving? I think so.
As for the pass rush, "can't get any worse" is actually quite a good reason to think that Conrad Obi and Marquez Herrod can improve the pass rush, and if Drew Hudgins gives us anything at all, that's a bonus.
For the running backs, all we've lost is Hugh Charles; he was a good back but he wasn't a star or anything. Sumler and Lockridge will be fine even if Polk and Scott can't give us much.
I'm not arguing that we are going to win 12 games; I'm just saying that there is no good reason to think that a team that played as many freshmen as we did won't get better. And there is certainly no good reason to think we will be worse, certainly not 3-9. That's bullsh*t.