There's a huge difference between who is able to recruit the best athletes/players projecting out of high school and who is able to develop the ones they get and how they end up doing in the NFL.
Doug Baldwin was a 2* recruit coming into Stanford and Richard Sherman was a 3*, FYI. I think Allbuffs would have thrown a fit had CU signed them.
Funny thing you mention the development because a couple years ago Stanford supposedly got the "dream team" of offensive lineman recruits but I read a couple articles last year criticizing the o-line play compared to prior years with those big time recruits. Probably just an blimp on the radar but we will see if it keeps up the next couple years or it they turn back to the team that went to the rose bowl two years in a row.