ROFLCOPTER
Member
Several important players were not available to Hill last year. Off the top of my head: 2 starting DL (one academically ineligible and one suspended), both starting safeties, one of whom is a first-team All-American (he broke his leg in a drill before the season and the other went down 3 games in with a broken arm), as well as their leading WR, who had to redshirt last year because he wasn't cleared early enough and will probably be a frosh All-American this year.I can agree that there are several question marks about D-Root, specifically his ability as a head coach and how successful he might be with his own recruits in place. However, what we do know about him is not lackluster. His defenses at AFA were solid. His defense at aTm improved dramatically in the first year under his tutelage. His defense at Fresno St is only giving up 22.2 points per game, and his team went from 4-9 under Hill the previous year to 9-3 in one year under Deruyter (this is with a new offensive and defensive system in place). There was absolutely talent on that team, but I'm not going to bash the guy figuring out how to utilize that talent effectively.
I still give an edge to MacIntyre, but as I've said elsewhere, I really don't think there's that much of a gap between the two gentlemen.