14-1?, they should've been in the CFP.Division II National Champion played a total of 15 games, started in September and was done before Christmas.
In order to do that these teams play a 10 game regular season.
View attachment 24721
14-1?, they should've been in the CFP.Division II National Champion played a total of 15 games, started in September and was done before Christmas.
In order to do that these teams play a 10 game regular season.
View attachment 24721
I hate this auto bid for P5 champs BS. So if an 8-4 team wins the Big XII title game, you want them in?
The thing I hate about Match Madness is the best team rarely wins the title. The more teams you add, the more the season and championship get devalued.
4 teams, or better yet, #1 and #2 play for all the marbles. That's how it should be.
How can you be the best team in the country if you aren't even the best team in your conference????
Conference titles don't make you the best team in your conference.Had this argument the other day with a Mizzu buddy. If your the best team then win your fricken conference, i just dont understand those that argue otherwise.
8-4 teams haven't earned the right to compete for titles.Yes, and when the 8-4 team beats the over-hyped and under-scheduled 11-1 ACC or SEC team, then maybe it'll sink in that polls don't always know everything.
Yeah, like when #2 Nebraska played for all the marbles after getting smoked 62-36 a few weeks earlier. THAT'S HOW IT SHOULD BE. <sarcasm font>
So, then National Titles don't make you the best team in the country?Conference titles don't make you the best team in your conference.
I don’t see why there can’t be 3 tv slots on Saturday. NFL gets an early game at 11 am, and then they pick if they want the 2:30 game or the 6 pm game.
Does the super bowl title mean you're the best team in the NFL? Hell no!So, then National Titles don't make you the best team in the country?
What is the point of any title then?
Maybe Tenn. is the only true champion left!
That's why you can't go to 8, 16, 32 teams. Keep it small, but it has to be based on conference champs. Can't be the best in the country and 2nd best in your divisionDoes the super bowl title mean you're the best team in the NFL? Hell no!
I hate playoff systems because the best team rarely wins the championship. I hate the idea that you just have to get hot at the right time rather than truly be the best.
11-1 team should get in over a confefence champ when everyone knows they are better. Alabama deserved to be in. Not Ohio State. Ohio State gave up 55 points to Iowa. Anything else they did this year was irrelevant because of that. Buf you want them in because they won your sacred conference title.That's why you can't go to 8, 16, 32 teams. Keep it small, but it has to be based on conference champs. Can't be the best in the country and 2nd best in your division
So then what’s the point of a conference championship (other than a money grab)? You’re potentially penalizing the team for winning their division and down playing the value in making it to the game. I don’t disagree with your assessment about Alabama, but there’s definitely a conundrum about who is worth advancing and on what terms the advancement should be based upon.11-1 team should get in over a confefence champ when everyone knows they are better. Alabama deserved to be in. Not Ohio State. Ohio State gave up 55 points to Iowa. Anything else they did this year was irrelevant because of that. Buf you want them in because they won your sacred conference title.
I think that's my main issue with how this shook out.So then what’s the point of a conference championship (other than a money grab)? You’re potentially penalizing the team for winning their division and down playing the value in making it to the game. I don’t disagree with your assessment about Alabama, but there’s definitely a conundrum about who is worth advancing and on what terms the advancement should be based upon.
So then, you agree that UCF should be in over Alabama, right? Their record is WAY better. They never lost. Beat everyone by an average of 20+ points.11-1 team should get in over a confefence champ when everyone knows they are better. Alabama deserved to be in. Not Ohio State. Ohio State gave up 55 points to Iowa. Anything else they did this year was irrelevant because of that. Buf you want them in because they won your sacred conference title.
No, only 2 teams should get the opportunity to play for the title.So then, you agree that UCF should be in over Alabama, right? Their record is WAY better. They never lost. Beat everyone by an average of 20+ points.
Maybe Alabama didn't play ANYONE legit, and lost to the only real team they played?
That is such a bull**** statement. Until they play the games, no one knows who is better. The biggest problem with CFB is that humans are involved in who is deserving. Every other sport determines who is deserving based on who won. In all other NCAA sports, if you win your conference you get the chance to play for your championship. Humans decide if others are also deserving of the opportunity, but if you win, you are in. Why should CFB be different. Are those decision makers that much more learned about the game that results on the field should be ignored?11-1 team should get in over a confefence champ when everyone knows they are better. Alabama deserved to be in. Not Ohio State. Ohio State gave up 55 points to Iowa. Anything else they did this year was irrelevant because of that. Buf you want them in because they won your sacred conference title.
Deserving is not the choice. Best is, not most deserving. Change the charter. It ain’t happening.That is such a bull**** statement. Until they play the games, no one knows who is better. The biggest problem with CFB is that humans are involved in who is deserving. Every other sport determines who is deserving based on who won. In all other NCAA sports, if you win your conference you get the chance to play for your championship. Humans decide if others are also deserving of the opportunity, but if you win, you are in. Why should CFB be different. Are those decision makers that much more learned about the game that results on the field should be ignored?
Does the super bowl title mean you're the best team in the NFL?.
Don’t want CFB like NFL. I like it is different. I’m not in favor of expanding post season. As a matter of fact, I’d like to see it contract (which I realize will probably never happen). Reduce the number of bowls and keep the playoff small.
No, only 2 teams should get the opportunity to play for the title.
Could leave out the best. Charter says find the four best. Not most deserving. But all k is that.You do realize only 2 teams do play for the title right?? The question being debated is how you whittle the season down to the 2 best teams. When season starts it should be open, but preseason ranking give a bias. Playing the teams in front of you is all you can do to make your case Step 1: play a respectable OOC. STEP 2: win your conference via a conference championship game. STEP 3: conference champions battle it out till down to 2 teams. STEP 4: last 2 teams left standing play for the title. Pretty simple really.
I'm not gonna support any system that just says, "you won your conference, you're in".You do realize only 2 teams do play for the title right?? The question being debated is how you whittle the season down to the 2 best teams. When season starts it should be open, but preseason ranking give a bias. Playing the teams in front of you is all you can do to make your case Step 1: play a respectable OOC. STEP 2: win your conference via a conference championship game. STEP 3: conference champions battle it out till down to 2 teams. STEP 4: last 2 teams left standing play for the title. Pretty simple really.
You don't honestly think that, lol.Yeah. It does.
Advanced analytics determines best. Not perception.How are they determined to be the best if they don't win their conference? By someones perception? Regardless, shouldn't you reward those you deserved it? Talk about a silver spoon.
I'm trying to think of another sport that doesn't have that exact setup for its playoff.I'm not gonna support any system that just says, "you won your conference, you're in".