He makes both. Often.Shilo is not dumb.
He does though get caught up in the game an let his emotions take charge of his play instead of his logic.
When the passion results in a good play we are happy, when it shows up in a negative way we get upset, in part because we have seen it before.
Given the option though I would rather have a guy making mistakes of effort and emotion than guys making mistakes out of a lack of caring which is what we had with KD and prior.
And the part about the “coach’s kid” is infuriating because of how much CP talks up Shilo, but we actually play better with his backup in.