Cincinnati doesn’t play a P5 schedule, but yes I do think they deserve to play in the CFP if they finish undefeated. They handed Notre Dame their only loss in South Bend and have dominated the rest of their schedule. For my money, the top 4 will be Georgia, tOSU/Michigan winner, Cincinnati, and one of OU/Okie St/Notre Dame depending who wins out. Bama would get the 4th spot with a win over Georgia and in that case Georgia still probably makes it in if the game is close.
Your problem is that you were so adamant that Tucker was a fraud early in the season that you’re now scrambling for stats to avoid having to admit he’s a pretty decent coach. I don’t expect you ever to actually admit it, but you look like a fool trying to rationalize your position now.
Lot of jilted lovers here hating on Tucker. I don't like him as a person but he is proving that he knows how to be a winning coach.
He left CU better than he found it, had we supported him and figured out how to keep him I have no doubts that we would be a much better program than we are now.
The program he took over at Michigan State wasn't devoid of talent but it was in turmoil as they hadn't planned on making the coaching change.
So people are putting him down for losing two games this year. He lost to a pretty talented Michigan team with an established coaching staff and a head coach who is well respected even though he has struggled some there. He also got blown out by Ohio State. Buckeyes were wanting to make a statement and they have what is either the second or third most talented roster in college football after Georgia and maybe Bama. They are loaded with guys who will be getting playing for paychecks within the next couple years.
To truly be successful at Michigan State he will need to be consistently beating Michigan, Penn State, etc. and figure out how to beat Ohio State but for a guy in his second year at the program he's done pretty well. Their boosters seem to agree being willing to fund a massive contract to keep him.
Generally I don't believe that G5 programs belong in the playoff. You earn your way in playing a quality schedule, not just a couple notable games.
Cincinnati though this year has the Notre Dame win and as you stated dominated in a tough G5 league. That along with the lack of 4 P5 programs with truly outstanding resumes gives them a good argument. You can find 2 or even 3 P5 teams with solid arguments to be included but not four who are better this year.
Their results though in the playoff will have some bearing on how G5 teams are looked at in the future. Get thoroughly outclassed and it might be hard to put another G5 in for a while.