It’ll depend on who has more freebies for the students. The school will have 15-20K students who want to be on TV. I expect that both will have great turnouts.I have a feeling the atmosphere for one of big noon or gameday will be flat.
We just had big noon last week, the shows start early in the morning, and the game doesn't start until 8 at night. Hosting one we would probably do fine but having an impressive atmosphere for both shows at the same time given the conditions seems unlikely.
I'm interested to see which show people flock to.
I personally think gameday has fallen off and prefer big noon.