For decades CU has settled on sub-par coaches with zero recruiting ability. Juice Box, Embree, HCMM, and Kardboard. None of them had any idea on how to recruit above G5 talent.
through the tenure of the coaches you mention above, recruiting has dramatically and fundamentally changed. every program has access to more data and the ability in theory to recruit nationally now. there are basically no more hidden gems. there are late bloomers and such but every program has far more access to reliable data than they used to.
the traditional powers who were able to capitalize on this (and who are also in great natural footprints) have had great success this way. bama, uga, clemson, michigan, and ohio state in particular have recruited lights out by leveraging national recruiting augmented by in footprint quality.
and, at the elite-elite level, the ability to augment national recruiting with the best quality in footprint guys has been the difference maker and why usc, uo, and uw have not been able to break through yet. this is why usc and uo hired the coaches that they hired-- go get more dogs from out of footprint because there are not enough dogs in footprint.
hawkins faced different challenges and recruited mostly about where we would expect at the time to recruit. if he had won, we would have been fine. embree knew what the roster needed to look like but he and staff were not ready or able to get the guys in. mm is a good coach but couldn't pull enough national guys as the talent was concentrating at winning programs to sustain anything. kd is the real outlier here. i am not sure what his strategy was, other than to pretend NIL didn't exist and that he could develop players himself. absolutely the wrong coach at the wrong time.
CU cannot recruit the way it did under Mac and win now. that era is over. Prime is a real-deal difference maker and his ability to pull guys nationally is unique. for us to sustain this, we need to win games. of course.
so far, Prime is the right coach at the right time and it is beautiful!