Bufffan68, I couldn't agree with you more. I can't remember the last time the Buffs hired someone who actually inspired confidence that he would be the guy to turn things around/get back to the level Mac had the Buffs at when he abruptly left after the 1994 season. Every single one of them seems like it was a lackluster hire that I had low expectations for, and which failed to even live up to those expectations, lol. Honestly, I guess Neuheisel and Hawkins were the only two of the bunch who I thought had a decent shot at turning out to be good to great coaches. Every other coaching hire has just been a total "meh/wtf?!" hire in my opinion.
Neuheisel was a weird one...the AD bypassed both coordinators (and Mac disciples) and elevated a position coach to HC. All of Neu-weasel's success came with Mac's players and ****...a dumbass like me could've coached that talent to a bowl game. LOL.
Barnett was a good hire and we were robbed, but he seemed to lose gas after Dorrell hired away Bienemy and Embree to UCLA.
Hawkins...or as he has been called on this site as "he who will not be named"...some will say he was an obvious and "sexy" choice, but I think a competent AD would've seen through him. Let's not play the very depressing game of "what if" we hired Peterson instead.
Embree was just sad...don't completely blame Bohn for that one as I heard his hands were tied financially and politically getting pressure to hire an alum. The QB sneak on 1st down is regrettable Buff lore.
Considering we were the worst P5 program in the country, MMac was a decent hire. He did a decent job making us not ****ty and gave us an amazing year in '16 with The Rise...but as more of a turnaround coach he was out of his depth as far as building a foundation for greatness. Tough to blame RG for the extension...but again "what if"...
Tucker looked like a good hire...good recruiting class and amazing pedigree. But he went 5-7 with a fairly talented team in a weak division. His fairly disastrous start at MSU has me wondering if he's any good. I'm guessing he's a great recruiter and will eventually get enough talent in to win...but as a coach...meh.
Who knows about Dorrell...great first game and maybe being 11th on RG's top 10 candidate list is motivating to him.
Thus ends my synopsis of Buff futility...some good years peppered in there...only one in the last 15 though.
Now it's time go sell some shoes and avoid having sex with Peg.