5-7. Year in, year out. That was pretty much were MikMac left off. 2016 was when everything came together. I give MikMac credit, but he was a 5-7 type guy. He did a lot of things well: dug the program out of the hole it was in, roster was balanced, he recruited some decent DL and DB talent, got his son PT, ran a clean program, solid, not spectacular, game day coach. He did not recruit across the board at a level to compete in the P12, especially the OL.
MikMac had topped out, Tucker was a good choice to take it to the next level, but the CU Administration had their hand on the chicken switch and Mel had enough savvy to get while the getting was good.
Dr. Phil, RG and LC all had their thumb in the pie and failed to land a quality replacement, and as far as I can tell, panicked and hired KD out of some weird combination of fear of rejection, loyalty to the Buff former player/coach network, desire to be good, but not too good, fearing problems a successful FB program can bring, and well, ineptitude.
It boggles the mind they made KD the highest paid CUFB coach in history and guaranteed all of it, given his HC history and utter lack of marketplace demand.