Well who knows how Noyer looked in practice. Some guys aren't good in practice, but step their level up in games.
This is also why I was constantly pissed that MM/MT wouldn't put in ****ing anyone other than Montez. You just never know what guys might do.
It is worth reiterating what NW said, Noyer did get some time and didn't look good. Granted, if memory serves, a lot of that time was vs Wazzu when their defense was legit and it was a ****ty rainy windy game, so he probably should've gotten more of a chance.
I also seem to recall Duff asking an open question before last season that was something to the effect of, "will we come to regret Montez starting at QB for 3 years?"
Yes. Very yes.
Also, don't forget: Montez = Ten Cent head! How many wide-open receivers did we watch him ignore with his locked-on-to-Viska stare?
nm, highlander beat me to it