Gundy was a good option for coaching about 5-15 years ago, but he is the worst possible option for today's college football, especially with empowered black players. I do not think they will be good again, they are as much an Oregon State as they used to be an Oregon. Pickens is gone, and they are second fiddle in a small state
I don't know. I think the main question in this saga was who could OSU get immediately to replace Gundy without destroying the program to its studs? The second question, does the football athletic department need to expand to remain competitive? I think OSU's admin was probably stuck since they had no great option and also needed reforms within the football infrastructure. Gundy had terrible season this year, yet so many 10+ win seasons in a tough place to play. They played in the CCG last year. Why not roll for another season? Other teams did this with embattled coaches.
I have a feeling that Gundy in agreeing to the contract restructure did not just flip that $$$ into NIL, rather it could go towards expanding OSU's football operations infrastructure. I think OSU has fallen behind in this regard. Some of the articles I read mentioned an overhaul vastly expanding so they are better in recruiting, retention, and the portal. Programs need the back end guys, which pay dividends if they are good. IMO, this is what Prime brought in and vastly improved year 1 to year 2, such that our portal and recruiting haul were much better compared to the past season. The past season was an upgrade but those were guys Prime brought with him alone, rather than competitive recruiting/portaling.
In this season's coaching carousel, only 4 P-4 teams parted with head coaches. A ton of programs are adding OC/DC or advisors with HCing experience, which I think are somewhat forced onto the head coach (aka Leavitt on MikeMac). I do not think this is a coincidence, as the new trend could be like MI appointing from within or at least having an interim option enough to stabilize things, even if that interim is not eventually hired. IMO, the AD's have to be very strategic with a longer term transition plan.
Next year, I think P-4 programs fire coaches earlier in the season, so they basically have a turn-key operation in place before the regular season even ends. This is regardless if the interim coach finishes the season well, as that could be Plan B. If Ryan Day lays an egg early next season, OSU many may not want Chip Kelly and CK may not want to HC, but they have a decent interim placeholder. Same with kNU, if Rhule lays an egg early, they have Holgorsen. FSU took on Malzahn. Other teams are following suit in this regard. These guys do not have to be the final hire.
I do not think a programs desire to be where UCF, West VA or UNC find themseleves facing a massive staff turnover/instability during recruiting or the portal period, plus not having people in place to salvage via the Dec Portal. Lincoln Riley did it well his 1st season, but has massively under performed since. I could be wrong but I think transitions will happen early in the season or maybe even after the Spring Portal sorts itself out. Although players can enter the portal immediately due to a HCing change, the players may be in school and have to finish the semester before they truly move.