You absolutely are right here. There is a difference, and a big one, between these newspaper properties. My point was that, at least for some papers, it is possible to be profitable in the modern age if you provide enough value. Those papers are doing it, and they have far higher costs due to what they cover, so maybe the DP could do it if they kept their vision narrow and their costs down. Hell, they are doing it, but they aren't making enough to defeat the money siphon that is their ownership.
But it is an interesting question. Just how much money can a revamped DP make per year?