AllBuffs | Unofficial fan site for the University of Colorado at Boulder Athletics programs
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
-
Prime Time. Prime Time. Its a new era for Colorado football. Consider signing up for a club membership! For $20/year, you can get access to all the special features at Allbuffs, including club member only forums, dark mode, avatars and best of all no ads ! But seriously, please sign up so that we can pay the bills. No one earns money here, and we can use your $20 to keep this hellhole running. You can sign up for a club membership by navigating to your account in the upper right and clicking on "Account Upgrades". Make it happen!
Official CFP Selection Freakout Thread
- Thread starter Alfred91
- Start date
They were 13-0 and won the best conference.
b3buffs
Well-Known Member
So the precedent is now set for injured starting QBs. Hope you enjoy that door being opened for what is to come.
The precedent set is for teams to deceptive with injury reports going forward.
Major injuries matter - I want to see the 4 best teams, not another TCU/UGA
hawg1
Well-Known Member
I’m lost on the argument. Make your case for FSU using the protocol.
I don’t care about the top 3.
Again, you are stating an opinion. You have absolutely no clue if that is true.
Playoff selections should never be subjective.
Why play the regular season then? Why not just go with the preseason ranking? After all, it's about talent on paper if games don't matter
Normally a top-two conference. It was #3 this season.
Bourbon Buff
Well-Known Member
And the SEC teams' SoS is based on them playing each other in the SEC, because their out-of-conference schedule was pretty pedestrian. It's kind of a backdoor conference ranking, perhaps with the SEC getting some favoritism via means that satisfy the protocol.
They did not have a watch party was my point
They had a lot of close wins and the good wins over Utah and USC are no longer top 25 now
Washington v Florida State besides QB could be an argument
hawg1
Well-Known Member
I guess I’d ask how you know differently. If you consider, FSU and Bama comparable (I do), the criteria say you choose Bama independent of conference ratings.You actually believe that horse ****.
It's a pretty similar argument to last year where people said TCU deserved it but weren't a top 4 team. Different circumstances but similar situation.Because clearly that TCU team was not capable of beating any top 2 team.
I think it is extremely naive to believe conference affiliation never comes up in discussions.
The protocol starts with "otherwise comparable teams" then gets into the tiebreaking bullet points you keep calling out.
To me, the undefeated record separates UW/Mich/FSU into one "otherwise comparable" group and leaves Bama, Texas, Ohio State, and Georgia in an "otherwise comparable" group.
The fourth spot then deals with conference championships, head to head record, strength of schedule, common opponents, and injuries/other factors.
The undefeated resumes of Michigan, UW, and FSU separate them from being "otherwise comparable" with anyone else. This year the CFP rankings consistently put undefeated P5 teams straight into the top grouping.
Big Jim
WTF?
Perfectly said.
The variable that the SEC could be shut out of the playoffs changed yesterday so the selection vaviables to justify backdooring Alabama into the playoffs changed.
Bama isn't a top 4 team either.
hawg1
Well-Known Member
Bama’s SoS advantage over FSU is clear. Conference strength is not in the protocol. Individual team SOS is. Bama wins on that point.
Yes they are & had the toughest SOS along w/ Texas
hawg1
Well-Known Member
Wins is not a part of the protocol. If it was, Liberty is in.
Subjective. You cannot prove it conclusively.
I've backed it up with a number of sources & said if JT wasn't injured FSU would be in
The P12 was the best conference this season by a wide margin. Close games in the deepest/best conference are expected even for top teams. I recognize that I’m biased because my system has its own player/team/conference power ratings. My ratings have P12, then B1G, <med. gap>, then $EC, <med gap>, then Big 12, then ACC.
F$U without JTrav creates a similar drop to Colorado without Shedeur (in terms of expected points). The drop is slightly mitigated by the quality of their defense. In simulating their games, F$U are definitely NOT anywhere near 13-0 without him (or a QB of his caliber).
Yeah those vaunted matchups against the juggernauts that are middle Tennessee, south Florida, miss st, Auburn and Chattanooga send shivers down my spine.
And counter arguments can be made. You are simply stating opinion.
Alabama had a significantly tougher SOS than FSU
When the argument is coming down to Alabama or FSU...
hawg1
Well-Known Member
Show us your SOS numbers.