That example is more about having a dynamic play caller, IMO, not whether a HC is a great gameday coach or not. Sure there are a few big decisions each game that a HC makes that go along with “gameday coach”, but I think he knows how to game plan, strategize, make in-game schematic adjustments, work the clock (for the most part) and just generally manage a game. He’s not special at it but he’s better than Tucker was/is.I don't really agree with this tale on KD.
He is a great teacher and coach of fundamentally sound football. He's not a great gameday coach.
KD does not, and would never in a million years call a flea flicker on our own 4 against NU.
He completely lacks the instinct to sense when there's an opportunity to do something great.
I’d also say that from what I’ve read on other 247 boards (and just obviously from performance), the negative recruiting against Coach Meat was at an all time high following him at Arizona and that first year here. Blackmon, Gonzalez, and Bethel looking good in coverage hopefully alleviates that (lol).On the plus side, getting rid of Summers appears to have been the right decision.
After a night to think on it, I'm absolutely convinced that setting the goal at "keep it close going into the 4th and see what happens" turned out to be the equivalent of a prevent defense.
Instead of seeing the opportunity to really put the game away in the first half, the coaching staff (starting with KD first and foremost) was content to play conservatively.
They had the other team on the ropes and lacked the killer instinct necessary to finish them off. The team had it - the coaches did not.
Not surprisingly, the same dynamic plays out of the recruiting trail as well. Call it being nice, call it being conservative, call it whatever you want - this program decidedly does not go out and get it what it wants - it waits for it to come to them.
**** - that's how KD got the job. He didn't go out and get it. He wasn't pursuing the opportunity from the beginning. He landed a dream job by "being patient and waiting."
Of course he's not going to go out and fight for a recruit, or a win.
If he wanted to be a head coach again, when the CU job came open he should have been all over it. Talk about not being able to see on obvious opportunity. Instead... he kept it "close" until the 4th quarter and saw what happened.
That's not a recipe for greatness. It might be a recipe for finishing a little above average.
These are both correct.See, I felt like going for it on 4th down inside the 5 was KD trying to win it in 1H. He had the chance to go up 2 scores and give a little breathing room, but he chose to really make a statement. Poor call to just line up and go QB sneak again, as their rushing success to that point wasn’t due to the OL physically dominating, but rather because they spread A&M out, worked double teams up front and let the RBs find the holes. He should have called a TO and come out with and actual play. One of a handful of brutal coaching mistakes that cost them the game.
Who are the young, lower ranked guys in the Secondary who have played much so far?Coach Meat is an excellent DB coach. Getting a lot out of the so called lower ranked recurited players. That should help in recuriting. The Freshmen look great.
Biggest play of the game for the defense, it’s clearly a passing situation and they call a defense that has Thomas with RB coverage responsibilities instead of pass rushing only. There has to be more situational awareness from Wilson and Coach Mike (and KD) to not allow that to happen. Barnes and Lamb HAVE to get more snaps, particularly against teams that want to throw to RBs and TEs, which is all A&M could doI didn’t get to watch until this morning.
terrible call not taking the three early in the game. Rushing seemed to be the hot hand in the first half. Just keep riding that horse! Bland play calling in the second half led to predictability. Where was Clayton and Broussard in the second half? If you’re going to call two straight sneaks, at-least put Stacks behind Lewis for the push.
not sure why Thomas was covering a key player on that TD? Nobody else was on that side from the look of it?
That offensive PI call was complete BS.
Chev needs a guy check. Start calling a good game, or GTFO. If he isn’t recruiting like he used to, then he is no use to the Buffs. That last drive was weird, four straight pass plays that were in front of the sticks?
Chris Wilson is a clear upgrade for DC.
I’m still happy with the game. Hanging with the no. 5 team with a good and experienced defense. Just sad that the fans from the Dr. Pepper Fansville got to celebrate in the end. Bring on the Gophers! Bring on the PAC12. The Buffs are due!!
I’m hopeful that CU outperforms and some of the ASU/UoA recruits that CU lost out on come to their senses and decide to flip when those programs flop (well, when ASU flops, UoA might go winlessI’d also say that from what I’ve read on other 247 boards (and just obviously from performance), the negative recruiting against Coach Meat was at an all time high following him at Arizona and that first year here. Blackmon, Gonzalez, and Bethel looking good in coverage hopefully alleviates that (lol).
Honestly, yesterday should be an EASY sell to recruits. Look at that top 5 recruiting team and how we hung close! We just need playmakers like you to get us over the top!
KD said he was going to be aggressive every time. We should get used to it.These are both correct.
KD and staff have been very passive in what they do.
Even when they step out of the norm like going for it on fourth down they went conservative rather than trust a player to make a decision (run/pass or pick a hole on an outside run.)
In the second half they went away from anything that called on Lewis to make decisions including the RPO stuff that worked against the Aggie aggression on D.
I like this scheme and personnel. I wish he was a little more aggressive on pass rushes.On the plus side, getting rid of Summers appears to have been the right decision.
There’s a strategic decision at play there and a tactical one. Strategy was aggressive, tactically the play calls were not.KD said he was going to be aggressive every time. We should get used to it.
Two sneaks is not aggressive
aTm covered both gaps and had MLB cocked and loaded.I don’t like the playcall but it’s not as crazy as people make it out to be. You are talking about a QB who was a stud power lifter in Texas with crazy squat and powerclean numbers. Putting him behind the strength of your line on the interior isn’t a bad plan but definitely could have been better, especially back to back
Doesn’t matter you have three lineman and one of the strongest pound for pound quarterbacks in college football pushing them. Lots of experience at the three interior positions including I think the strongest player in the team with pursell.aTm covered both gaps and had MLB cocked and loaded.
Who are the young, lower ranked guys in the Secondary who have played much so far?
It was an offensive pass interference call and it was a bad call. The receiver and db were hand fighting and when the receiver pushed the db, the ball had already been caught.Can someone who was watching on TV tell me about the penalty that negated the long first down gain? It was either holding or offensive PI I think. You guys were calling it a bill **** penalty.
Yes it matters. Purcell got smashed. At minimum you set to right or left in that situation. No all sneaks work no matter who you have. Yesterday’s got blown up.Doesn’t matter you have three lineman and one of the strongest pound for pound quarterbacks in college football pushing them. Lots of experience at the three interior positions including I think the strongest player in the team with pursell.
It was 3rd and 1.Didn’t mind on 4th down but wasn’t it like 3rd and 2? Odd yardage for a QB sneak
Two down strategy. I thought it strange but OK.Didn’t mind on 4th down but wasn’t it like 3rd and 2? Odd yardage for a QB sneak
Bad call. Appeared to me that the ref screwed up by dialing in looking for a potential pick play, lost sight of the overall play, and threw the flag when he saw the full arm extension on the push - not aware the push was bang-bang after the catch.It was an offensive pass interference call and it was a bad call. The receiver and db were hand fighting and when the receiver pushed the db, the ball had already been caught.
They brought in the former official and rules expert on the broadcast who said it shouldn’t have been called because of that.
If your best offensive player and your offensive identity is built around your RB, you've got to give him at least 1 of the 2 opportunities.I don't know who made the call. I don't mind the 2 consecutive sneaks. The decision was probably made on 3rd that we were not going to settle for a FG. The way we were moving the ball, you would think we would be able to score with 4 downs from inside the 4. It just didn't work out. Maybe we need to practice that play more. Lewis did not seem selective with where he was going with it.
I don’t recall any of them getting meaningful snaps at CB this week. Highly recruited Gonzalez, JC transfer Blackmon and Miami transfer Bethel were the studs at CB yesterdaySo called 3 star and 2 star recruits like Taylor, Moore and Niko Reed.
Again, you are talking about the outcome which is totally different than the input (strategy). Doing a QB sneak behind three of your better and more experienced players on the team and with one of the strongest quarterbacks in college football isn’t some crazy play call. Could and should we have done something different? Of course.Yes it matters. Purcell got smashed. At minimum you set to right or left in that situation. No all sneaks work no matter who you have. Yesterday’s got blown up.
The issue is percentages here. Arias has shown us for 4 freakin’ years that he can’t catch. Yet he’s the go to now? Recruiting matters. Dude would be 3rd on the depth chart anywhere else.Arias catches that ball down they sideline and this is a different conversation