Menu
What's new
By:
Filters
AllBuffs | Unofficial fan site for the University of Colorado at Boulder Athletics programs

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • Prime Time. Prime Time. Its a new era for Colorado football. Consider signing up for a club membership! For $20/year, you can get access to all the special features at Allbuffs, including club member only forums, dark mode, avatars and best of all no ads ! But seriously, please sign up so that we can pay the bills. No one earns money here, and we can use your $20 to keep this hellhole running. You can sign up for a club membership by navigating to your account in the upper right and clicking on "Account Upgrades". Make it happen!

Shedeur Sanders - 2023-25 Tracking History Thread - Drafted by the Cleveland Browns (NFL)

The Cleveland QB room is interesting to say the least.

Joe Flacco is a fan favorite from the 2023 season, but hasn’t been a full time starter in the league since 2017. He is ancient, but an experienced guy that would be good mentoring the young QBs.

Kenny Pickett is a former first rounder that washed out in Pittsburgh and was a backup for Hurts in Philly. He has 20+ starts in the league and is still young. Cleveland spent a minor amount of draft capital to trade for him.

Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders are rookies.

Deshaun Watson will likely be on IR all season and then cut.

The QB room is usually three in the NFL. Who do you cut? Flacco is past his prime but would be a good mentor and may be able to hold the fort for a year as you bring the rooks along. Do you cut Pickett who you just traded for?

You normally might be able to stash someone on the practice squad if they can clear waivers. Can either Shedeur or Gabriel clear waivers? Doubt it.

Maybe you bring both rookies through training camp and then trade one of them or Pickett for a QB desperate team?
 
Creebuzz said:
The Cleveland QB room is interesting to say the least.

Joe Flacco is a fan favorite from the 2023 season, but hasn’t been a full time starter in the league since 2017. He is ancient, but an experienced guy that would be good mentoring the young QBs.

Kenny Pickett is a former first rounder that washed out in Pittsburgh and was a backup for Hurts in Philly. He has 20+ starts in the league and is still young. Cleveland spent a minor amount of draft capital to trade for him.

Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders are rookies.

Deshaun Watson will likely be on IR all season and then cut.

The QB room is usually three in the NFL. Who do you cut? Flacco is past his prime but would be a good mentor and may be able to hold the fort for a year as you bring the rooks along. Do you cut Pickett who you just traded for?

You normally might be able to stash someone on the practice squad if they can clear waivers. Can either Shedeur or Gabriel clear waivers? Doubt it.

Maybe you bring both rookies through training camp and then trade one of them or Pickett for a QB desperate team?
Click to expand...
The last one is most likely IMO. Give them both a start in preseason, make your internal grading, and then see what kind of trade offers you get.
 
Not sure if it means much but they declined to pick up Pickett’s 5th year option. Feels like the preseason will be Pickett, Gabriel and Shedeur each getting a start with at least one getting cut, if not two.
 
manhattanbuff said:
Our arby play was not good last year either. Considering how bad that part of our offense was, pretty amazing how potent it was.
Click to expand...
Ask any RB if they enjoy running that Shotgun handoff from a stand still?
Garbage option for a good Running Game
Get under center and run stretch zone or have more ball faking with fly motion or anything that helps move the defense eyes
He had Pat Shurmur, and it felt like if the goal was to also help SS get top draft opportunity, then go more Pro, even with a weak OL, be creative
 
4BienemyTDs said:
Ask any RB if they enjoy running that Shotgun handoff from a stand still?
Garbage option for a good Running Game
Get under center and run stretch zone or have more ball faking with fly motion or anything that helps move the defense eyes
He had Pat Shurmur, and it felt like if the goal was to also help SS get top draft opportunity, then go more Pro, even with a weak OL, be creative
Click to expand...
College football is almost always run out of the shotgun and tons of teams have good rushing attacks out of the shotgun, it isn't a shotgun issue. No desire to run the ball, bad OL, mediocre RBs - not a good combo
 
The Alabaster Yak said:
My primary concern is that Kevin Stefanksi and Andrew Berry might not even want him. I know they came out and said that Haslam had nothing to do with it, but IMO, taking Gabriel over Shedeur kind of says a lot about how those two individuals view the two QBs.
Click to expand...
I am almost certain Hassan made that call. Listen to the phone calls they had with Gabriel and Fannin. It was all “we’re excited to have you, can’t wait to get to work, we want you” etc.

Then listen to their call with Shedeur. “You gotta get here and earn your keep. Make sure you work hard”

They aren’t trying very hard to hide it
 
Corey Trevorson said:
College football is almost always run out of the shotgun and tons of teams have good rushing attacks out of the shotgun, it isn't a shotgun issue. No desire to run the ball, bad OL, mediocre RBs - not a good combo
Click to expand...
There was an interview with Terrell Davis or some other big time RB, and he said how most of them do not understand the use of Shotgun draw plays where the back has no chance to build up any momentum or to be able to set up the defender. Yes there are some successful teams, but there are proven ways to just run the ball and no need to rehash that we were the worst running team pretty much ever
 
4BienemyTDs said:
There was an interview with Terrell Davis or some other big time RB, and he said how most of them do not understand the use of Shotgun draw plays where the back has no chance to build up any momentum or to be able to set up the defender. Yes there are some successful teams, but there are proven ways to just run the ball and no need to rehash that we were the worst running team pretty much ever
Click to expand...
Whether you agree or not running the ball in cfb is overwhelmingly out of the shotgun, especially with the evolution of the RPO. Will see some offset formations & some pistol but being under center makes it much harder to run RPOs and reduce the # of options within the play.
 
4BienemyTDs said:
Ask any RB if they enjoy running that Shotgun handoff from a stand still?
Garbage option for a good Running Game
Get under center and run stretch zone or have more ball faking with fly motion or anything that helps move the defense eyes
He had Pat Shurmur, and it felt like if the goal was to also help SS get top draft opportunity, then go more Pro, even with a weak OL, be creative
Click to expand...
There’s no talking sense to you. It’s the past.
 
MtnBuff said:
Worst thing is that with all that has happened this week if Shedeur doesn't want to be again portrayed as the bad guy he has no real option except to accept the apology and move on rather than insist that Jeff Ulbrich be held accountable as well as the young idiot.

The coach has an obligation to secure private information that is in his control. This means no "accidental" leaks and his son knowing that anything he might incidentally see is to be kept quiet.

The son doesn't get a pass because he is a "kid." If you told him he requires additional supervision and restrictions because of his age he would certainly get upset. If he's old enough to make those decisions he's old enough to be responsible for the consequences.

The team is responsible for supervision of it's employees. An appropriate response from the league would be to take away a draft choice, maybe a 5th or around there. Let the coach explain to the management why his lacking concern should cost the team a draft choice.

Meanwhile though with the narative about him be ego driven and self-centered he is stuck not reacting which won't gain him anything among the haters but if he does respond with any anger the will be the one who gets portrayed negatively.
Click to expand...
It’s PII the Falcons can be held accountable.
 
BUFFset said:
It’s PII the Falcons can be held accountable.
Click to expand...
And while the league has a contract with the players union that includes some limits on punishments available for players there is nothing like that for coaches. As long as it doesn't violate state or federal labor law the league can levy whatever consequences on a franchise and on coaches it wants to.

As you mention it is PII. A team or coach would have a hard time arguing in court that the league is not within it's authority to impose a punishment for violating the privacy of a prospective player.
 
As I think a bit more about SS's slide, there are many factors at play. A few thoughts I centered what things would an NFL draft team look for in a polished pocket passer coming out of college? I think some of it was the offense we ran, blessed with excellent receivers, but also not a running game or top notch line. I look almost entirely at 2024, since Shurmer was here the full year and the line was somewhat serviceable for stretches. I list the following boxes for a pocket passer:

1. Throw good balls to all three levels w/ vertical passing game--SS showed this.
2. Throws well on the run--SS mostly showed this.
3. Bubble screen game--SS checked this box.
4. Avoid turnovers and not get overwhelmed--SS showed this. SS started a few games slow but for the most part came on in the 2nd half. We won 9 games.
5. Make some plays with legs--SS mostly checked this box.
6. RPO, Play Action or use deception--we didn't really do this much at all.
7. Dumping off good balls to the RBs on time with some space--we didn't run this.
8. Throwing to the TE--we didn't do this. For a pocket passer, this would be something most NFL teams would really look for, even if it was forced. They would want to see that check down executed to the TE but also the slot as well. TH being in the slot made this much easier at times.
9. Getting the ball out fast/hitting the hot read--SS did not really show this too much, some with the bubble screens/slot; but many of CU's plays were slower developing.
10. Effectively direct a running game mixing run and pass audibles. Mostly CU/SS checked into the big play and SS did not show he was captain run game adjusting runs one way or another. Peyton Manning won Denver the SB playing over BO (who played good at the end of the season) because he could direct the run game so well even with a rag arm.
11. Improvisation--SS showed he could extend plays, sometimes making big plays, but sometimes eating a bad sack. This is something some young QBs just excel. I don't think SS showed a bunch of this trait.
12. Throw the ball away, avoid getting hit, and the huge negative plays--we did not do this.
13. Going through progressions and making tough reads--I think this was probably a mixed bag of sorts. I'm not sure how the NFL teams evaluated this one way or another; but for those NFL front offices the broken down film would not lie.
14. Play under center--we didn't do this much.
15. Show excellent pocket presence/be nimble in the pocket. The Oline limited this a bunch, however I saw on occassion SS stepped up in the wrong place or abandoned a pocket early. If CU had one solid side of their line, I think SS might have been able to demonstrate this much better.


I do think with time, learning, hard work and a legitimate chance, SS can still develop. For what it is worth.
SS should not have slid as far as he did, as he was tough, successful and a winner last season.
 
dio said:
he took too many sacks, but watching the games he was taking those to make plays and to win games. I was mostly ok with a lot of the sacks he was taking. Because he makes plays to win games.

He hopefully doesn't feel forced to do that in the NFL
Click to expand...
I saw it kind of differently.
 
manhattanbuff said:
Our arby play was not good last year either. Considering how bad that part of our offense was, pretty amazing how potent it was.
Click to expand...
snl season 42 GIF by Saturday Night Live
 
Let's make three Shedeur predictions. It can be silly, legendary, smart, dumb, stupid, or interesting

Here is my 5 predictions

1. Shedeur will start as QB4 this spring and eventually make it till QB2 for Mr. 44.

2. Kenny Pickett will beat out Flacco who will be released. He will start the season as the 41st QB of the Browns.

3. In the 4th game in the 2nd quarter, Pickett will either be pulled or get hurt. Shedeur come in and win the game turning the Browns into a 2-2 team.

4. With the curse of euclid finally being lifted on April fools of all days in 2025, Shedeur will be named the 42nd starting QB of the Browns in the 5th week of the 2025 season. He will lead the Browns to a super bowl title and win SB MVP and NFL offensive player of the year as well as the NFL rookie of the year.

5. Shedeur will win 8 Super Bowls, lose 5 Super Bowls and play for 24 years passing Tom Brady as the all time 🐐.

070b3858-d035-4f85-ab45-b9dc9681b2c9_text.gif
 
Last edited:
#1 pick said:
Let's make three Shedeur predictions. It can be silly, legendary, smart, dumb, stupid, or interesting

Here is my 5 predictions

1. Shedeur will start as QB4 this spring and eventually make it till QB2.

2. Kenny Pickett will beat out Flacco who will be released. He will start the season as the 41st QB of the Browns.

3. In the 4th game in the 2nd quarter, Pickett will either be pulled or get hurt. Shedeur come in and win the game turning the Browns into a 2-2 team.

4. With the curse of euclid finally being lifted on April fools of all days in 2025, Shedeur will be named the 42nd starting QB of the Browns. He will lead the Browns to a super bowl title and win SB MVP and NFL offensive player of the year as well as the NFL rookie of the year.

5. Shedeur will win 8 Super Bowls, lose 5 Super Bowls and play for 24 years passing Tom Brady as the all time 🐐.
Click to expand...


1. Shedeur will look good in camp and his start in the preseason.

2. Cleveland will trade him based on the "equity" gained in #1.

3. He will be the starter at the end of the year.

4. He will be in the conversation for ROY (but Hunter wins)

5. Next spring, his team will not shop for a starting QB in free agency nor will they try and draft one.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top