I tend to agree with most of your comments and many others. It seems on that particular play noted, it appears SS dropped to a pass, when the play call was a run in a 80K+ stadium with a ton of crowd noise, hence no coordination. @NE was an awful half of football that put CU behind, then the O has to try playing from behind, not a good recipe. Things spiraled into halftime. The D played better in the 2nd half, and created chances in the 1st half too. That game was a nightmare, so let's turn the page.
On O, I want to see improvement, a good-game plan and executing/sticking with the game-plan, even if it is not the prettiest of wins. I don't like all the negative comments pointing to Daddy ball, as I like SS (probably the most talented NFL caliber QB CU has ever had), however if wants to be a QB1 in the NFL draft (i.e. 1st round pick), SS will have to demonstrate that he can simply execute a game-plan, which includes running the football. If it were to be "Daddy ball," Prime is doing no favors in making the O one dimensional. They have to compete in the time of possession category in the 1st half, which they did not do in either game. IMO, those Oline guys have to be given an opportunity to get off their blocks and just punish going forward (i.e. they have to eat too). Obviously, the RBs have to hit the holes, whoever it is that plays. Cannot forget, the over-riding weapon in the CU offense is exploiting its play-makers for big plays, which are at the QB and WR position--so they can't abandon all their "shots." They have to hit the plays--that is protection, big and small throws and catching the ball. I think we all agree, every other play does not need to be a "shot." I'm not sure there is perfect balance or O system to be had in a 2024 CU O, but an O that executes enough putting points in the board and just wins game is it. A "W" is a "W" and that is it.
On D, put two halves of football together and we build off of that going forward. I thought both teams hit hard last week, and the D has to keep doing that. It will not be perfect, but play really hard as they did both 2nd halves. I would love to see some turnovers and more sacks. I think those will come, if we are not playing from behind and the time of possession battle is manageable. There is not much they can do about CU's quick strike O (which we had v. NDSU), but better O execution can hopefully help with time of possession.
Special teams, they just have to convert. Same sort of execution. Mata has to be autoMataca, or other options. Our punter has to be in the running for B-12 punter of the year. We brought in a certain return guy, and he has to break some plays.
Finally, the coaches just have to be on the same page with each-other and the players. That includes SS. Maybe with his Heisman hopes dimmed, he can maybe dial down the run to pass checks, and have the O run the ball more or look for quick short chunk plays moving the sticks. @cu3x, I like many of your comments, but I don't think they are going to double-down on SS's Heisman hopes, since to realistically win it, CU needs to win 8-9 games with some tough away games--which means dialing back SS's passing on some days. Hunter could be in the running for a Heisman, but if they run Hunter so heavily on O and D, he will get banged up. With Hunter, some teams may double or bracket him on O, then SS needs to exploit other guys in certain games and maybe more runs. Same thing with SS's on usage, if he passes 40-50 times game holding onto the ball waiting for downfield plays, he is going to get hit a bunch even without huge sacks. He needs to understand the running the ball, if it not all that successful/dominant can give him some breather plays keeping him healthy. That is where I dispel Daddy ball, since I don't think that Prime, SS or Hunter get to where they want to be respectively (Heisman/respected coach) with just throwing the ball piling up stats like Hawkins did in his final year. A 6-6 or 7-5 regular season would meet/beat many expectations (Vegas projections), but will not bring a Heisman to CU.
Let's go into Canvas and get it done, just get the "W," however it comes. Same with Baylor. Both games try to stay healthy and get guys back too. The larger changes and more offense schemes/positon changes may start some with CSU, but really put in after the bye week. Go Buffs get the W!